This is a many-faceted issue, so let me make myself clear, I support the free-flow of goods, services, and labor between all individuals. I am a libertarian, and my primary focus is on respecting, and protecting the rights of each individual, including the Right to travel unimpeded, upon Public roadways and thoroughfares.
I had to preface my statement to make it clear that ‘open borders’ does not mean ‘no borders’, but it does mean that if anyone wants to come into the ‘land of the free’; and they are clear of communicable disease and/or representing a threat to Arizona’s Citizens; there’s no reason at all to deny them the opportunity to further contribute to our economy.
Given that there are those politically-motivated interests who would wreak havoc on the innocent Public, and do represent a threat to Public safety it is essential that ‘We’ know who is coming in, and why. Unfortunately, as long as there are governments claiming and dominating territorial jurisdiction, and as long as governments attack other governments, physical border security is a rational part of government’s tasks.
There are other considerations, for instance; each year around 160-170 people die in Arizona’s deserts, trying to get to America, a final act of desperation for many. We cannot tolerate this inhumanity, nor can we tolerate the blatant abuse of taxpayer’s funds by those who have come only to take advantage of ridiculous laws that promise ‘free money’ that act as a magnet for them.
So, what is ‘my’ solution? Thanks for asking. I think we have to secure the borders, to actually stop bad actors from coming here and, by opening access, we take away any reason for good people to come here ‘illegally’. I do think it’s important to know ‘who’ is visiting Arizona.
Although Arizona could offer State Citizenship, and through the reciprocity Clause, “American Citizenship”, I wouldn’t support that at all. It’s up to Congress to determine the steps to U.S. Citizenship, and I will leave it in their hands.
Something that needs to be confronted is the drain on Public resources by those coming here to take from, not contribute to, our economy. The solution I favor the most is simple, if people want to work here, that’s fine. They simply request a work pass. They won’t have to be paid under the table, or gipped out of pay at the end of the day by unscrupulous employers threatening to call I.C.E. on them.
I will propose that if anyone coming in wants to work here, they need only register for a work pass. A work pass allows them to work wherever they want. Along with the pass, I will propose a 5% work fee. The funds would go into an account specifically to provide for the needs and wants of international visitors, such as education, or medical attention. The account should be managed by people from among those visiting, with only limited oversight by government. The responsibility would rest with the account managers, not Citizens of Arizona.
I do not believe any kind of blanket ‘amnesty’ would be appropriate, and I am not referring to Citizenship with voting rights. At the same time, Arizona will be far more peaceful and human beings can come out of the shadows. My proposal will include a 90-day grace period for all currently illegal residents to register with the State, and if appropriate, request work permits. If they don’t present a threat, they can return to their homes.
My proposal is Not ‘amnesty’, and it’s not Citizenship. It stands to reason that the only ones who will not register are those who do represent a threat to Arizonans, and at the end of the 90-day grace period, any unregistered visitors will be immediately deported and not allowed readmission for 5 years.
This proposal leaves no reason for anyone, other than bad people, to cross our border and illegally trespass on private property. It will put the coyotes out of business, and cripple the human trafficking trade. We’ll secure our border ourselves. I won’t wait for the federal government to do something.